I recently rewatched Pay It Forward, one of those movies suburban families and elementary schools alike seemed to collectively decide every kid needed to see. I actually loved it when I was younger, but somehow I hadn’t thought much about it since. Then I spotted it for $4.99 in Apple’s digital store. Can we still call it iTunes? I honestly don’t know. Apparently, I’m old enough to be nostalgic for a digital storefront.
Anyway, I bought it, watched it again, and was surprised by how much I still liked it.
I’d also seen some pretty harsh opinions about the movie on Letterboxd and Reddit. A lot of the criticism focuses on the characters being too flawed, the story being too sentimental, or the whole thing being unrealistic. And I get it. Pay It Forward isn’t exactly subtle. There are moments when it practically grabs you by the shoulders and says, “This is the part where you feel something.”
But I actually think the flawed characters are what make it work.
The Messiness Makes It Real
Trevor, played by Haley Joel Osment, is tasked with the assignment of helping three people in a meaningful way and asking each of them to pay it forward by helping three more. It’s an incredibly optimistic idea, especially coming from a classroom assignment, but the movie doesn’t pretend people are simple.
Trevor tries to help Jerry, a homeless man struggling with addiction, played by Jim Caviezel. Trevor brings him home, believes in him, and tries to help him turn things around. Then Jerry falls off the wagon, and Trevor is heartbroken.
Watching that as an adult hit differently. Sometimes you help someone and they still struggle. Sometimes you give someone another chance and they still mess it up. You can care about someone deeply and still have absolutely no control over what they do with the help you give them.
And then Jerry encounters a woman who’s about to jump from a bridge. He tells her he’s paying it forward and saves her life. He then asks her to get coffee.
I love that scene because Jerry isn’t magically fixed. He’s still flawed and struggling. He has already disappointed Trevor. None of that disappears. He simply does something good when another person needs him.
That’s far more interesting to me than a neat redemption story where someone makes one good decision and suddenly has their entire life together.
Also, Jim Caviezel is fantastic in this movie. And if you haven’t watched Person of Interest, please do yourself a favor. No notes. Ten out of ten. Somehow more relevant now than when it aired.
What I Took From It This Time
The older I get, the more I like the idea behind paying it forward because you’re not really supposed to get anything back. You help someone and let the outcome belong to them.
That’s harder than it sounds. We like proof that what we did mattered. We want the thank-you. We want to see the person get better. We want to know our effort wasn’t wasted.
But you don’t always get to know.
Someone might remember a kindness you’ve completely forgotten giving them. A teacher might say something to a kid that sticks for twenty years. A friend might check in on a terrible day and never realize how badly that person needed it.
People may forget what you were wearing or exactly what you said, but they often remember how you made them feel. It’s a cliché, but clichés usually survive because there’s some truth hiding in them.
That’s why I don’t really mind that Pay It Forward is sentimental. I’d rather watch something occasionally lay it on a little thick while asking a sincere question than spend two hours being cynical just to prove it knows the world is complicated.
The movie reminded me that you don’t have to have your life completely together to do something good for somebody else. You don’t have to fix a person to help them. You don’t even have to know whether your kindness will “work.”
You can just pass something good along.
Maybe that’s checking on someone you’ve been meaning to call, helping a person who’s having a rough time, giving someone another chance, or doing something kind without needing anyone else to know about it. And if it means something to them, ask them to pass it on.
No grand gesture required. No inspirational Instagram post necessary. In fact, please don’t make me watch you film yourself buying someone’s coffee.
Just do the kind thing.
I still think Pay It Forward can be a bit cheesy. Of course it can. It’s a movie about a child trying to change the world through kindness.
But after watching it again all these years later, I don’t think its optimism is as unrealistic as people make it out to be. People are complicated. They screw up. They disappoint each other. They struggle. But even in all of that, they’re still capable of doing something good.
And sometimes, you have no idea how far that one good thing will travel.
Leave a Reply